How does opposition to Rand Paul's "Fourth Amendment Protection Act" even make sense for ITAPS? The federal FAPA says exactly one thing: electronic records held by third parties are inadmissible in criminal proceedings unless obtained under consent or under color of a specific warrant demonstrating cause.
What are the business implications of such a law? Google and Facebook have no obvious commercial interest in the outcome of random criminal cases.
Isn't it a lot more likely that Vice just doesn't know what it's talking about and has gotten the bill wrong? That rather than opposing the "Fourth Amendment Protection Act", they're opposing individual state FAPAs derived from the 10th Amendment Center's Model State FAPA, which can hold a corporation in violation of state law for honoring a federal subpoena or court order, which would (a) create potentially 50 different new data protection policies and (b) put Internet companies in an absolutely impossible position of needing to choose between violating either a federal law or a state law?
How does opposition to Rand Paul's "Fourth Amendment Protection Act" even make sense for ITAPS? The federal FAPA says exactly one thing: electronic records held by third parties are inadmissible in criminal proceedings unless obtained under consent or under color of a specific warrant demonstrating cause.
What are the business implications of such a law? Google and Facebook have no obvious commercial interest in the outcome of random criminal cases.
Isn't it a lot more likely that Vice just doesn't know what it's talking about and has gotten the bill wrong? That rather than opposing the "Fourth Amendment Protection Act", they're opposing individual state FAPAs derived from the 10th Amendment Center's Model State FAPA, which can hold a corporation in violation of state law for honoring a federal subpoena or court order, which would (a) create potentially 50 different new data protection policies and (b) put Internet companies in an absolutely impossible position of needing to choose between violating either a federal law or a state law?