> "The biggest issue with absolute positioned layouts (as with design for print)
is they can only scale, but not adapt to the various resolutions"
There's no reason you couldn't do exactly the same thing media queries do using JS i.e.
if(window.innerWidth <= 320){ layout.apply('mobile') }
> "If everything has fixed dimensions; it wouldn't be very reusable."
In my experience, practically speaking, there isn't much reuse of components anyway. How often do you put a sidebar widget in the main body? And if you do how many presentational overrides do you need to include to make it look good in it new home. Also using JS for layout doesn't mean not using CSS at all. Instead CSS can be used for what it's actually good for -> text styling.
> "JavaScript performance in newer browsers are pretty good,
but ranging from extremely to pretty bad on older browsers"
I dont think there are that may constraints to track on a usual webpage. Updating 15-20 nodes would (i'd guess) be 50-100ms on page load.
> "The amount of reuse you'll get from even writing a decent
interface for layout functions will be pretty low."
sorry not sure what you mean here.
> "Behavior of CSS using a reset is more consistent than JavaScript implementations."
No reason you couldn't use both. A reset mostly deals with normalizing presentation issues, not css layout issues.
> "that means using something like jQuery"
Many (most?) sites are already including jQuery.
> "specific layouts (ex. keeping an element always visible) as repositioning "
That's an edge case which could be worked around.
> "Waiting for your JavaScript to be downloaded and interpreted to reposition elements "
There's no reason the initial downloaded layout couldn't be already positioned correctly and therefore not requiring a layout operation on page load. A re-calculation of layout is only necessary if the DOM changes, eg some new content is loaded via ajax.
> "You should invest time in pre-processors such as Stylus, Less or SCSS "
These are great, but they're pre-processors which limits their usefulness.
