it's better because 1) it falls out of the regular semantics of the language. it's just a regular if expression. it's a consequence of a more elegant and unified design, in other words. that ternary syntax by comparison is ad-hoc. to begin with, it's the only ternary operator in those kinds of languages. (thus people call it "the" ternary operator). it shows poor design restraint, imo

2) it's not punctuation. a ternary expression is a 3-input mapping to begin with. punctuation only makes it noisier.