Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And do you think we defeated the nazis by leaving their food intact? By leaving their bomb factories intact?

Did we refuse to invade their cities in case the innocent nazi citizens got killed?

War is war. I don’t see a single person in that territory that opposes the war. They simply want the other side to surrender because they are losing a war they started.



No all war doesn’t constitute genocide. Nor is genocide justifiable if you think it’s effective. Mass murdering children crosses a fundamental moral line. Children are innocent. Israel has lost any moral basis for its war through its dark, “ends justifies the means” reasoning.


You have replied:

> And do you think we defeated the nazis by leaving their food intact?

to the parent comment saying:

> 28% of children under five are actively malnourished.

> IPC Phase 5 famine is officially confirmed in Gaza. 100% of the population is facing crisis level food insecurity.

Can you clarify what you mean? I don't think you somehow believe genocide is necessary or something like that.


Do you realize that words like "they" and "the other side" are greatly reductive and lack much needed nuance?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: