Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wow, this is huge.

There are so many other things described in ancient texts that have yet to be discovered. Herodotus for example is filled with references to places and things that were later discovered. However there are still many examples of pretty credible places and objects that remain undiscovered.

Also, fwiw, people for some reason think it’s ok or cool to criticize Herodotus’ history. It’s actually very good and he always says when he observed something for himself, or it’s something that is said by others and he felt it was important to document. However his assumptions and methods are always stated. I think honestly the main problem is it’s just a really long book so few ever read it.

Thucydides is even better.

It’s such a shame there is virtually nothing surviving from people who personally knew Alexander. His entire rise is foreshadowed all throughout Thucydides, which is amazing considering that it predates him considerably.



> It’s such a shame there is virtually nothing surviving from people who personally knew Alexander.

To me it's also just incredible how short his life was, and I imagine that contributes to how scarce first-hand accounts are. He started taking part in military campaigns at 16, became king at 20, and was dead by 32. The Wikipedia article about him mentions he had a historian (or more than one); it's a shame none of those accounts survived to today.

Sure, life expectancy back then was not what it was today, but he was still fairly young, and did a remarkable amount of conquering and expansion in a decade.


I like the way Bob Briar describes Herodotus as an ancient tourist/journalist.


> It’s such a shame there is virtually nothing surviving from people who personally knew Alexander.

Did you forget the guy who's texts were the foundation of our civilization? Most of Aristotle's works are lost, but there is still much to read from Alexander's tutor.


Nothing surviving from people who personally knew Alexander (written about him*)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: