Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This isn't really a robot, more of just a remote-controlled boat. Still cool and a great idea for helping people who are drowning, of course. But seems misleading to call it a "robot", which (to me at least) implies some level of autonomy and more tech than you'd find in toy RC cars from 30 years ago.


The price tag also seems like the people want it to be marketed as a robot. You could strap a motor and RC controller to a floatation device and waterproof it for less than a couple hundred dollars. Why do things that are meant for safety always have to be insanely priced?


You could also put the operator on a jetski directly


> Why do things that are meant for safety always have to be insanely priced?

When your product fails you may be liable for an injury or death.


While greed is surely some of the answer, I’d imagine liability also plays a part. If your device fails to save someone, you could be a target for litigation.


i thought was just a backpack until it took off


Yeah, if you look at the photos it's just just an RC boat with some stuff strapped to the top.


Industrial "robots" often (generally?) have very little autonomy. It's helpful to not be constrained to the human form.

What is a robot? An automated laborer.


Industrial robots are autonomous: they do not require an operator.

An RC car requires one.


Many follow a sequence of predefined triggers. They're as autonomous as a belt-fed machine gun, or an internal combustion engine.

ROVs are piloted. https://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/explainers/technology.html

UAVs? Also robots. Even if they're piloted.

Bomb Disposal... Robot.

An RC car? Probably a robot.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: