Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That style of Weller soldering iron really is the best. Too bad prices has become even more crazy. I managed to get a WHS M for €200 back in 2010 (which was a good deal, but nothing extreme). Now they are going for €500. Is there still no competition?


A used Metcal/OKI RF iron is a good investment. They're pricy, but if you're using lead-free (and if you're modifying something soldered elsewhere, you probably are), they just work. Even a Hakko struggles on ground pins with lead free solder with a smaller tip and the OKI just does it in a second.

By avoiding even a couple of days ruined by hellish rework drama, it's paid for itself.


I thought you meant the OKI that make printers xD But apparently this is OKInternational. I'm not finding an RF though... perhaps FR? Those look very much like Hakko FX-100 tip-wise, and while i take your word for it that they are good, the Weller design seems superior to me.


RF as in radio frequency. They work by sending radio energy down a coaxial cable to the tip where it's absorbed. At the desired temperature, the tip alloy reaches its Curie point and stops absorbing energy. The instant it cools, it absorbs again. It's a far faster control loop since it's all physics and doesn't require a sensor (with some non-zero level of thermal impedance between it and the tip itself), no separate heater element (the tip is the heater, again with that thermal impedance) and feedback to the controller.

The downside is the only way to change temperature is to change tip to one with a different alloy. In practise, this isn't any kind of issue because the only reason you usually need to ramp the temperature with a conventionally-heated iron is because you are trying to compensate for the heater-tip-sensor feedback loop being unable to keep up when soldering big things, which is a problem the Metcals don't really have in the first place.

The Curie point system as what the FX-100 uses too, so probably they're as good for the same reason, but they don't seem to have a good second-hand supply like the Metcal/OKIs (I scored an OKI power supply for under $100, but even if you don't get lucky they're relatively cheap).

Also if you're into that kind of thing, the MX-500P-11 at least has schematics of the entire power supply that have been reverse-engineered (notably it appears to contain no microcontroller).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: