Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Does anybody have any stories of how devices like this revealed a problem -- what the problem was, does an air filter fix it, etc?


Yes...formaldehyde exposure is a big issue in the US. Not many know of it. I bought a new construction house, so it has new carpet, paint, cabinets, wood flooring etc has an off gas effect. I honestly it's criminal to allow builders to build like this, or material to be manufactured like this. That "new car" smell, that smell when you open up new furniture made of plywood (the glue contains formaldehyde) .

There are threshold laws in the US and Europe. There are laws from OSHA that regulate where you work - but no laws that regular where you sleep! It's all driven by money, of course...material with lower formaldehyde cost more to manufacture. Just walk into a Sherwin Williams and compare their paint. The highest ones are eco friendly "Low VOC" (volatile organic compound) - so industry definitely knows about it.

The numbers in my house were effectively off the charts and OSHA would be closing down your employer if you had this exposure at work.

Remediation for this is essentially allow to off gas, keep windows open. Off gassing also is impacted by humidity, so may be low during winter but high in the summer or when it rains.

Air filter DOES NOT fix this. The amount of air moved by a HVAC is peanuts compared to just opening windows for a few minutes.

California has regulations: https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/our-work/programs/composite-wood-prod...


Some filter vendors like Xiaomi offer active carbon filters to capture formaldehyde. Not sure how well it performs but I notice it captures odours well too.


> The numbers in my house were effectively off the charts

Did you get a measurement done, and if so where do you go to get that?


I got a formaldehyde detector. A "Dumb" one (https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00SIYDUUM/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b...) and also a Foobot - which is an IoT detector.

They generically measure "VOC".

The only reason why I knew of this is because my wife is from China and it's more regulated (kinda funny, isn't it?) and people know to let their house breathe before moving in. Otherwise I'd be celebrating our "new house smell"...which would prob linger for months and months in an average American home since families don't like to open windows.


You would be surprised how much particulate certain cooking methods produce, your home can go from 0 AQI to forest fire levels for a few hours without a filter.

With the right filter and sensor, you can keep your AQI in the single digits consistently and react appropriately to particle buildup. If you have a CO2 sensor as well you can react to CO2 buildup which is something I have experienced plenty of times in a modern apartment (not necessarily dangerous levels but levels high enough that cognitive effects should be expected). It is hard to keep indoor CO2 levels anywhere near outdoor levels without forced ventilation with the outside or living in a large house.


We have an indoor purple air sensor with a color gradient indicator (from green all the way to purple and many gradients in between). Exactly as you've said we are surprised at the number of times cooking has turned the air quality horrible indoors. Further we are able to see how when air outside is smoky from wildfires that the internal air filters are doing their job. Definitely worth the cost for us in the Bay Area: https://www2.purpleair.com/products/purpleair-pa-i-indoor


Do you have any recs for the right filter and sensor?


Someone referred me to https://oransi.com/ and I purchased one of the large EJ120 models. I've had it running for a few days and my place no longer has a smell and the air just feels clean. It's bizarre.


Nice, thanks for the recommendation. Is the EJ120 very audible? Where do you place it? Like someone mentioned elsewhere, the spouse approval factor is relevant for what air filtration solution I go with... haha


Doesn't look like any of those have sensors, unless I missed that? I guess one sensor is your nose in this case, ha.


HEPA filters which include a claim for 99.97% filtration (HEPA is put on a lot of things that are much less useful) Honeywell makes good ones.

MPR 2800 furnace filters for the box fan contraption. 3M makes good ones. Your furnace might not appreciate how much they slow down flow.

IQAir monitors are unreasonably expensive and IOT nonsense, but still good.


I have a xiaomi air purifier with AQ detector. Scrubber seems to to help with allergies. Detector itself is pretty much a glorified smoke detector Tamagotchi toy for me. I haven't found much use for it other than to keep numbers as low / nominal as I can. For which living in a pretty clean part of the city with good air quality means being more mindful when I cook to reduce smoke. That said the high AQ alarm has saved me a couple times from leaving stove top on / burning pots. Kind of paid for itself in that sense.


There was a time when my air quality sensor (a Temtop device) showed suspiciously high PM2.5 in the kitchen. It turned out the kitchen oven had too much oil build up inside and required cleaning. And no, I tried both cheap and expensive air purifiers; none of them could beat opening the kitchen window or turning on the range hood (a dedicated one, not the kind attached to a microwave). In this particular case, it was also a good reminder to clean the oven.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: