Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

explain how China is the world's fastest growing economy and has the fastest growing living standards while being one of, if not the most protectionist countries on earth?

According to most economists and their textbooks their growth should be terrible because they are so anti free trade

The only people who benefit from low tariffs are the rich, who can then outsource production and ship goods back into the country with no consequences. That's why income inequality has skyrocketed in the last few decades. The supposed savings of outsourcing weren't passed back to consumers, it was pocketed by the rich



I wouldn't say tariffs are China's reason for success or anywhere near it. That said, China and the US are drastically different.

It seems that most of their protectionist polices are about moving China from dumb labor into a tech hub. Global companies are forced to partner with a local business. This keeps some profits in China as well as locks businesses in and gives the local company the ability to do its own designs or even just steal IP outright. While frustrating, this is actually a pretty cheap exercise for the global entity. Sign a deal, do some meetings, fill some paperwork and boom you have access to a billion users and very cheap labor. The cost of competition comes later and many many businesses take the deal.

Contrast this with tariffs that are just a dumb tax that immediately bite into profits and don't directly promote growth locally. If you actually want to target US businesses, you'd be supporting subsidies not tariffs.

>The supposed savings of outsourcing weren't passed back to consumers, it was pocketed by the rich

I mean, this is just clearly false. The savings literally have to be passed back to the consumer or the Chinese goods would not out compete local goods and there would be no problem.


USA and a number of Western countries are waaaay more protectionist than China.

The idea that China is the most protectionist country in the world is no more than a meme.

Ranks of ease of market entry are very objective proofs of that.

It gas been definitely easier to setup a viable business in China than in US for a few years now.


>It gas been definitely easier to setup a viable business in China than in US for a few years now.

Where are you getting that information? Every international index disagrees with that assertion.


Ease of doing business report only deals with formal legal requirements and paperwork, but running business is not only about law/tax compliance.

Access to labour, facilities, depth and readiness of local market to accept new things - all that matters.

I am not agreeing with assessment that legal compliance in USA is easier than in China at all. USA has hideously complex tax system, you can't do a single thing without a lawyer, and any dealing with securities is past all hope for a person who have not purposefully studied that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: