Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Does seem competitive vs CNCs. But what are its benefits? CNCs might have higher set-up costs but are incredibly accurate.


Correct on the accuracy, but you can design parts with features like undercuts and cavities on 3D printing that are either not possible, or much more expensive, to CNC.

Not every metal part requires the 0.001" tolerance you can get with CNC as well.

I look at it as another technology that can be selected when the parameters make sense for it. I'm more familiar with plastic technologies, for them I switch between FDM, SLS, SLA, Polyjet and Injection Molding depending on:

- Forecasted quantity

- Time to market needed

- Price constraints

- Accuracy and surface finish required

- Design requirements

Each technology has it's own advantages and disadvantages.


It's the running costs. If you want to make a lot of the same part and need a 5 axis mill, they have to be operated by technicians which are extremely expensive and they can't work on anything else.

Make a lot of parts on a printer and you spend a little more time designing the part and time to tune the settings (which might be done depending on the material you use) and you're off and printing and just paying for print time. Not cheap, but cheaper than paying techs at mid-scale.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: